TLC's 90 Day Fiancé has featured many monogamous couples over the last eight years, but there have been times when certain cast members juggled more than one partner, setting the stage for disaster. There are even reality stars who've been with multiple people throughout all of their relationships.
Elizabeth Potthast (also known as Libby) featured alongside her Moldavian partner Andrei Castravet on the show. Although the couple had many ups and downs in their relationship, Libby didn't hesitate to follow her husband's Orthodox Christian religion, and got baptized before their second wedding. Omar Albakour and Avery Mills are also still going strong, despite their cultural differences. Ex-cheerleader Avery was once a Christian, but she changed her religion to Islam. The former 90 Day Fiancé cast member is now living a happy married life with her husband, while embracing the traditions of her new faith.
Related: Which 90 Day Fiancé Season 9 Couples Are Still Together? (Spoilers)
Jewish Ariela Weinberg also showed a big heart when she let her Ethiopian Orthodox partner Biniyam baptize their baby boy, Aviel Shibre, into his faith. While the 90 Day Fiancé season 9 star didn't appreciate the idea at first, she honored her partner's religion, which strengthened their relationship. Many stars have pushed the limits to make their monogamous relationships work. However, a few have preferred to keep their options open, by juggling multiple partners on the show.
One such cast member is Colt Johnson, who first appeared alongside Larissa Dos Santos Lima in 90 Day Fiancé season 6. The couple never actually had a real spark, which led the Las Vegas native Colt to divorce his Brazilian wife and move on to Jess Caroline. While Colt's second relationship began on a sweet note, he was already in love with his friend, Vanessa Guerra. Colt cheated on Jess with Vanessa, which led to his second messy breakup.
Another star who juggled two partners at once is Corey Rathgeber. The former cast member is famous for his tumultuous relationship with Evelin Villegas; they've split up many times. Since their debut on the show, there have been many rumors about the two cheating on each other. However, things got real when Evelin dumped her beau, and he went to Peru. As the couple was on a break, Corey used that time to build another relationship with a woman named Jenny. However, Evelin soon reconciled with her American partner, which led to many complications. While most 90 Day Fiancé fans wanted Corey to leave Evelin for Jenny, he ended up staying with his original partner.
Stephanie Davison was engaged to Ryan Carr during 90 Day Fiancé season 8. When the couple first appeared on the show, their age gap and long distance relationship seemed to be the only problems. However, viewers soon saw that the 52-year-old woman was insecure about her Belizean beau cheating on her. However, fans didn't realize that it was Stephanie who had cheated on Ryan all along, by sleeping with his cousin, Harris Flowers. While the former reality star described it as a misstep on her part, she did come clean about it to Ryan, which ended their relationship towards the end of 90 Day Fiancé season 8.