Warning: Possible Spoilers Below For Reacher Season 2!Reacher season 2 will replace many main characters from season 1, which could spell trouble for the series in 2 major ways. Based on Lee Child's Jack Reacher novels, Amazon's Reacher stars Alan Ritchson as the formidable titular vigilante. In Reacher season 1, he intends to stop at the rural town of Margrave only for a few days. However, he ends up extending his stay and joining forces with Oscar Finlay and Roscoe Conklin to solve a conspiracy linking to his brother's murder. As Reacher season 1 progresses, Finlay and Conklin become a significant part of Jack's crime-solving endeavors, and the former U.S. Army military policeman gets romantically involved with Conklin.
Unfortunately, since Reacher is a self-proclaimed hobo who avoids outstaying his welcome, he will move on to a different location in Reacher season 2. While this change in setting could benefit the Amazon series, it will exclude Finlay and Conklin from its narratives and replace them with new characters in Reacher season 2. Considering how the 11th book, Bad Luck And Trouble, in Lee Child's Jack Reacher novels is among the series' best offerings, it is great news that Reacher is adapting it in season 2. However, the character replacements in season 2 could create some problems for the Amazon show.
Roscoe, Finlay, and Reacher's dynamic worked well in Reacher season 1 because the two Margrave citizens were Reacher's opposites. While Reacher was more aggressive with his approach towards solving the overarching crime in season 1 and often got his way by using his brawn and brute force, Finlay and Roscoe were more procedural. Although this contrast initially created tension and conflict between the three, especially between Reacher and Oscar, it later showed how they complimented one another after they showed some signs of cooperation in their team-up.
Their opposing qualities were also the source of many running gags in Reacher season 1. For instance, when they rendezvous at Jolene's Chicken Shack in Reacher season 1, episode 3, Reacher eats an entire buffet, including two fried chicken thighs, fried okra, ribs, collard greens, pole beans, rice with giblet gravy, and cottage cheese with peaches. Meanwhile, Roscoe has a buttermilk chicken sandwich, and Finlay settles for spinach salad, much to everyone's amusement. Reacher season 2 may not be able to match season 1's subtle character humor, given how it will feature people from Jack's old military unit, who will be similar to him in many ways.
As trained members of the Margrave Police Department, Roscoe and Finlay could stand their ground in both hand-to-hand and gun combats. However, compared to a near-superhuman killer like Reacher, they were just "regular" cops who played by the books. This dynamic will change in Reacher season 2 since the titular character will join forces with his former team members from the 110th MP Special Investigations Unit. Considering his colossal stature, Reacher will stand out among his comrades, but not as much as he did in season 1.
RELATED: Reacher Season 2 Bringing Back Roscoe Would Be A Huge Mistake
David O'Donnell is one of the many characters from Reacher's military past who will join him in his season 2 crime-solving endeavors. According to the Lee Child books, David may seem like a regular white-collared worker but carries ceramic weapons to get past metal detectors. His choice of weapons itself reveals how ruthless he would be compared to Roscoe and Finlay. Karla Dixon will be another addition to Reacher's team in season 2. She may not be as big and intimidating as Jack in appearance, but easily overpowers her enemies in combat.
Dean McKenzie, another former member of Jack's 110th MP Special Investigations Unit, will also be a part of Reacher season 2's roster, suggesting that the titular character's allies will be nearly as strong and skilled as him. While this means that Reacher season 2 will have more opportunities to feature slam-bang action scenes, it could potentially harm the season by diminishing Jack Reacher's appeal as the larger-than-life imposing protagonist, especially during action sequences. Additionally, with Reacher's team being full of experts from the military, the stakes for his mission will be far lower than when he had relatively more ordinary people like Roscoe and Finlay by his side.
Replacing the main characters from Reacher season 1 in season 2 can have upsides too. For instance, Alan Ritchson's Jack Reacher is supposed to be stoic and a loner by nature. These traits make his romantic developments with Roscoe in season 1 rather odd, given how he knew he would have to leave her anyway after solving the Margrave case. If Karla potentially becomes Jack's love interest in Reacher season 2, the show can at least justify that their shared experiences and camaraderie from the military forms the basis of their relationship. This could make Jack's romantic endeavors in Reacher season 2 more organic and believable, unlike his Reacher season 1 relationship with Roscoe.