Cosmopolitan (UK)

And Just Like That viewers spot Harry and Charlotte timeline mistake in new episode

Cosmopolitan (UK) logo Cosmopolitan (UK) 23.06.2023 13:24:19 Lydia Venn
and just like that viewers spot harry and charlotte mistake

And Just Like That is finally back on our screens for season two, and we could not be more excited for the return of Carrie, Miranda and Charlotte.

In the two episodes that have dropped on Max so far, we've had an opening montage full of steamy sex scenes, plenty of Che Diaz and of course that pigeon clutch bag.

But whilst viewers have been loving seeing their favourite SATC characters return, there is one rather annoying timeline detail that has got viewers irritated.

In episode two 'The Real Deal' Charlotte (Kristin Davis) is grappling with her teenage daughter Lily (Cathy Ang) selling all her designer clothes (we wish we had Chanel at 15) to a company called The Real Deal to pay for a new keyboard.

Charlotte spends an entire dinner with husband Harry (Evan Handler) and best friend Anthony (Mario Cantone) complaining about not getting any acknowledgement from the company. Harry then jokes: "Good luck. I'm still waiting for any acknowledgement from my mother and she's been dead 10 years."

Erm, 10 years? Any SATC fan will know Harry's mother has been passed away far longer than a decade.

ICYMI, one of the biggest plot lines for Harry and Charlotte's relationship was that after they began dating, Harry revealed to Charlotte he promised his mother before she died, he would marry a fellow Jew. Charlotte eventually converted to Judaism in order to be with Harry and fulfil his mother's wishes.

That plot line took place in 2004, nearly 20 years ago, meaning Harry's mum died at least more than 20 years ago.

Something isn't adding up and fans of the series are not happy with the continuity error, with many taking to social media to share their thoughts on the timeline issue.

One person said: "Wait I thought Harry's mom died before he first met Charlotte? What is this timeline?"

Another said: "The complete and utter lack of continuity is doing my head in.1) Miranda's gloves during the beach phone scene. 2) Pretty sure Harry's Mum had passed before him and Charlotte met. Not 10 years ago."

And another wrote: "Harry's mom died before he met Charlotte that was the whole reason she converted to Judaism so they could get married after he broke up with her because she wasn't Jewish, it was a huge story arc in #SATC & not 1 person spotted this error?! Terrible writing."

As fans of the show have pointed out, Charlotte's storyline about converting to Judaism was easily one of her biggest and most important, so it seems a little odd for the maths to be incorrect.

We're really hoping Harry was just joking or being flippant in the moment.

vendredi 23 juin 2023 16:24:19 Categories: Cosmopolitan (UK)

ShareButton
ShareButton
ShareButton
  • RSS

Suomi sisu kantaa
NorpaNet Beta 1.1.0.18818 - Firebird 5.0 LI-V6.3.2.1497

TetraSys Oy.

TetraSys Oy.