It's interesting to argue that what we know today as a "fandom" would have not existed without Sir Conan Doyle's detective short stories from the late 19th century. In fact, the stories were so immensely popular that in 1964 they held the the second place for the highest sales worldwide after the Bible. The widespread popularity can be assigned to no other than the characters of the obsessive Sherlock Holmes himself and his trusted companion Dr. John Watson.
Interest - indeed, investment - in the dynamic duo by the film industry throughout the years has been unprecedented. A wide range of people, from directors Guy Ritchie to Paul McGuigan, has taken a different approach to the methodical detective and his story. All of them had a different actor in mind to portray the weirdly unique detective and his habits. Take a look at these seven actors who have done the best job.
In 2012, CBS came out with Elementary, a modern adaptation of the Sherlock Holmes stories, starring Jonny Lee Miller as Holmes and Lucy Liu as Dr Joan Watson. Instead of the usual British environment, the story is set in New York City where Holmes helps the Police Department solve crimes. Before its release and during the first season, the series received criticism for premiering close to the BBC's Sherlock series. It didn't take long until the audience fell in love with Miller and Liu's beautifully written friendship.
Though the show itself is a bit weak, Miller shines in his title role. His portrayal adds so much realness to the character's personality and the heavily implied autistic tendencies are performed outstandingly by Miller. From refusing to let anyone close in season 1 to promising he wouldn't leave Joan in the end no matter what, his character experiences a well-earned development.
The great Henry Cavill has quietly worked through multiple iconic performances, from DC's Superman to Napoleon Solo to the unique portrayal of Sherlock Holmes in Netflix's Enola Holmes (2020). Although the Netflix movie adapted the first book of the same name by Nancy Spinger and focuses primarily on Sherlock's younger sister Enola (Millie Bobby Brown), Cavill nevertheless found room to show off his brilliant acting skills. The different take on Holmes' character angered The Conan Doyle Estate, who decided to sue Netflix for violating copyrights, since Sherlock was depicted as having emotions.
Related: Sherlock: Should There Be a Benedict Cumberbatch Movie?
Many find the unique take on the character refreshing as it shows that a higher intelligence doesn't necessarily mean you have the right to be rude to others. That said, don't get it twisted: Cavill's character is still sharp as ever with his deductions, but with a nicer approach to his surroundings.
English actor Basil Rathbone notably took on the iconic role of the savvy sleuth in 1939's The Hound of the Baskervilles, marking his first of 14 films portraying the beloved Arthur Conan Doyle character. The gothic mystery is the first time a Sherlock Holmes big-screen adaptation was set in the Victorian era (like in Doyle's novels) and also featured the detective in his distinct uniform. With his dashing charisma and bold brilliance, Rathbone truly made the role his own and became synonymous as the ultimate Holmes, setting the precedent for future portrayals.
The performer would also collaborate with his co-star Nigel Bruce (appearing as Dr. John Watson) for the popular and long-running radio series The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, doing so from 1939 to 1946, which coincided with the cinematic pictures. Rathbone left his mark as Holmes, and his pairing with Bruce has been touted by historian Jim Harmon as "near perfect casting."
Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law star alongside each other as Holmes and Dr. Watson in Guy Ritchie's 2009 period mystery film Sherlock Holmes, in which they fight off an immense threat that endangers the whole of England. With the excellent guidance from Ritchie, Downey used his wit, which we so often saw in the MCU, to give his own personalized sparkle to the famous character. Many have argued that Downey's depiction of Sherlock is quite extroverted because of the actor's inseparable charisma.
However, there's no doubt Holmes is still closed-in on himself and only truly confides in Watson. The movie was followed by Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows in 2011, and fans are also impatiently waiting for his third Sherlock installment, which was supposed to be released in December 2021. Downey earned himself a Golden Globe Award for the Best Actor in a Comedy/Musical for this role.
The late Peter Cushing was an icon of Hammer horror films, so he naturally didn't shy away from an offer to play the character of Sherlock Holmes in a Hammer setting. He has played the eccentric detective three times: in his phenomenal movie The Hound of The Baskervilles (1959), in the 1968 TV series Sherlock Holmes and in another 1984 TV series The Masks of Death.
As many other BBC shows, some of the episodes with his unforgettable performance were lost until uncovered again in 2020. For many, Cushing represents a portrayal of Holmes with the needed classical ambiance. What's additionally significant is that The Hound of The Baskervilles was the first Sherlock Holmes movie in color.
The BBC TV series Sherlock, appearing intermittently from 2010 to 2017, starred Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock and Martin Freeman as Dr Watson, and is probably the most mainstream of all the adaptations. It's been praised for perfectly setting the tone for a modern take on the detective's life with its writing, acting and directing. Sherlock's popularity can be surely traced back to the chemistry between Cumberbatch and Freeman, which has created a huge fandom for the duo's relationship.
Related: Exclusive: Martin Freeman Turns Down 'Nice Guy' Roles, Wants to go Darker
Of course, there's no denying that Cumberbatch's acting has depicted Holmes' neurodivergence, mixed with intellectual confidence and emotional vulnerability, as outstandingly as ever. The actor was nominated for and has won numerous awards, including the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actor in A Miniseries or a Movie in 2014.
The 1984 TV series The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is accepted by many as the definitive version of Sherlock Holmes. Jeremy Brett (Holmes) stars alongside David Burke (Dr Watson) across 42 different short stories of Sir Conan Doyle. Brett, as a bisexual man, inarguably understood the underlying, emotionally complex queerness of Sherlock Holmes' character like no other. Scenes like when he destroyed a crime scene to prove how smart he was perfectly depicted the famed character's boldness and occasional ethical ambiguity.