While Nathan Fillion may be saving the day and solving crimes with his current procedural series The Rookie, the fan-favorite actor previously thrilled audiences on the comedy-drama series Castle as its eponymous, crimefighting protagonist Richard Castle. Running on ABC for eight seasons from 2009 to 2016, Castle was tentatively slated to reach the ninth season, with Fillion slated to reprise his starring role, only to be abruptly canceled. Here's why ABC ultimately changed its mind and pulled the plug on Castle rather than proceed with its plans for a ninth season.
Richard Castle was introduced at the start of the series as a bestselling mystery author who was brought in to consult with the New York Police Department after a copycat murder mimics the plot of one of Castle's novels. Castle works closely with police detective Kate Beckett, portrayed by Stana Katic, with Castle permitted to shadow Beckett and the NYPD for inspiration for his new novel series. While there is initially friction between Castle and Beckett due to Castle's more immature personality and Beckett's by-the-book professionalism, they eventually become friends before falling in love and getting married in Castle Season 7. The end of Season 8, which turned out to be the series finale, featured a flash-forward ahead seven years, with Castle and Beckett continuing to live as a married couple and parents of three children.
RELATED: The Rookie Makes an Unexpected Casting Move Before Season 5
There was speculation that Castle Season 8 would be the series' last, with Fillion and Katic both only signing one-year contract extensions following the conclusion of Season 7. Ratings for Castle saw diminishing returns over the course of Season 8, averaging under ten million viewers per episode, which was the lowest for the series and a marked decline from Season 7's average viewership. This led to reports that a potential Season 9 would see a reduced production budget, including shortened episode order and a smaller main cast. The proposed changes to Castle came as ABC saw a change in network leadership behind-the-scenes, with Channing Dungey becoming a new executive replacing Paul Lee. Lee was the Head of ABC throughout most of Castle's run and was replaced in Season 8's final months.
Like most new executives, Dungey came onboard to ABC with her own vision for the network's future, and this included a decision on where to take Castle next. Lining up with reports that a planned Season 9 would see a reduced budget, Katic and fellow series regular Tamala Jones were not set to reprise their roles beyond Season 8, while Fillion and much of the core cast signed a one-season extension. Given that Castle revolved around the relationship between Castle and Beckett, fans were shocked at the decision for the series to tentatively move on without Katic. This fan outrage was fueled by rumors of on-set friction between Fillion and Katic in contrast to their characters' dynamic. In the face of this controversy, ABC officially cancelled Castle exactly one week after announcing Fillion had extended his contract for a planned Season 9.
RELATED: The Rookie Is About to Make Its Fans Mad in Season 5
After eight seasons, it appeared Castle's time was limited, regardless if it had continued beyond Season 8. Declining ratings and contract renewals one season at a time signaled a series finale was on the horizon. This coupled with new leadership heading the network and fan discontent over the reduced budget and omitting Katic resulted in ABC deciding to forego the ninth season entirely. Castle was a decided success for ABC when it premiered in 2009 but, eight seasons later, slipping ratings and behind-the-scenes politics led to it coming to an abrupt close.
Created by Andrew W. Marlowe, all eight seasons of Castle are currently available to stream on Hulu.