The Independent

Boris Johnson news - live: PM's majority slashed as social care changes pushed through despite Tory rebellion

The Independent logo The Independent 23.11.2021 10:43:42 Sam Hancock
Boris J.jpg

LIVE - Updated at 08:34

Boris Johnson saw his 80-seat majority shrink in the House of Commons last night as MPs approved controversial changes to England's social care system, by a margin of 272-246 - a majority of 26.

Some 19 Tory MPs joined Labour to vote against the amendment - which bars means-tested contributions made by local authorities on behalf of some pensioners being counted towards the £86,000 cap - while dozens of others, including former PM Theresa May and ex-health secretary Jeremy Hunt, abstained.

The measure now faces further opposition as it moves to the House of Lords, where Lady Finlay has said peers will "scrutinise" the government's reforms "very carefully". She told BBC Radio 4's Today programme this morning: "It may be that we will say to the Commons, 'can you think again?' ... because, clearly, there's a lot of disquiet".

Changes to the Health and Care Bill announced just days ago will save the government £900m a year by making a proposed cap on lifetime social care costs significantly less generous for poorer pensioners, while allowing wealthy home-owners to pass the majority of their assets on to their children.

Follow our live coverage below

Earlier, speaking to BBC Breakfast, health select committee chairman Jeremy Hunt said he abstained in Monday night's crunch vote because he was "conflicted" about the government's approach.

He said: "I was conflicted, I actually ended up abstaining because it is a big disappointment that they changed the way the cap is calculated.

"But it is, nonetheless, a step forward."

Not including council support in calculating whether the cap on care costs has been reached means it "won't protect the assets of as many people as we had hoped for," he said.

"We should still remember that for the poorest people they will get more help, earlier, than they currently get."

Hunt will today push for the government to publish independently verified assessments of current and future workforce numbers in health and social care every two years, as MPs continue examining the Health and Care Bill.

Hunt, speaking to the BBC's Nick Robinson, is swiftly grilled about why he refused to take part in last night's vote.

"If you thought [the changes] were progressive enough, you'd have voted for them wouldn't you?" Robinson puts to him plainly.

Amid a rambling answer, Hunt says clearly "yes" he would have but that he "wasn't happy" with the change made last week.

However, pushed to explain why the PM had gone back on his promise to protect the public's asset, and to ensure families didn't have to sell their homes, Hunt says "it's not entirely accurate to say people will have to sell their homes ... it's more that we'll be helping less people than we originally thought to protect their assets".

He adds "people like me" were not overly happy with the changes and that it makes the Health and Care Bill "harder to package to country".

Talking more broadly about the last few weeks in parliament, Hunt says the "last month has not been a good month for the government". But, he insists "the thing that will count at the next election" is if the party is "helping everyday people with everyday issues".

Robinson intervenes to ask if he thinks that is the case - pointing out social care and northern rail train issues as indicators this is not the case.

Hunt responds that the UK's "booster jab scheme is the best in Europe" and gives people confidence in the government.

Jeremy Hunt - who has already confirmed, via an appearance on BBC Breakfast, that he abstained from the social care vote - is appearing on BBC Radio 4 Today now.

The former health secretary is expected to be quizzed on the controversial cap, so stay tuned for lines from him.

Here's a parliamentary schedule for today (Tuesday 23 November):

House of Commons

12.30pm Health and social care questions

1.30pm Urgent questions/statements

A 10-minute rule motion on Climate Education

Health and Care Bill - report stage (day two) and third reading

A short debate on Ickford and flood risk in planning

House of Lords

2.30pm Oral questions

3.10pm Dormant Assets Bill - third reading

Armed Forces Bill - report stage

A Labour MP has branded last night's Commons social care vote "absolutely shocking", saying it is the people "with the most modest houses and the most modest incomes" who are being cheated by the changes.

"It is completely unacceptable," Sarah Owens told Sky News, "and it doesn't even fix the social care crisis."

Going after Boris Johnson for breaking another of his promises, Ms Owens said: "[Mr] Johnson promised the electorate - and people voted on the basis - that people wouldn't have to sell their homes to pay for social care.

"But last night, [the Conservatives] whipped their MPs to vote for just that - it is an utter disgrace."

"What we saw last night was absolutely shocking"

Health Select Committee member Sarah Owen describes the changes to social care as inherently and failing to solve the "problems people are facing right now"#KayBurley

Read more: https://t.co/SlZOze1Z2j pic.twitter.com/upqkN39HKH

Baroness Finlay of Llandaff has said the House of Lords will "scrutinise" the government's social care reform "very, very carefully".

The professor of palliative medicine, and a cross-bench peer, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I think when this comes to the House of Lords, we will need to scrutinise this very, very carefully.

"We will do what the Lords does well, which is go over every line, discuss everything in this and we will want to see the assessment, too, of the overall funding.

"So, I don't think there will be any quick response one way or another, but I think we will spend quite a bit of time scrutinising.

"The impact assessment will be very important and we will need to know the detail because we will need to scrutinise it."

She added:

"It may be that we will say to the Commons, 'can you think again?', it may be that we come up with constructive amendments to improve what is on the table at the moment because, clearly, there's a lot of disquiet."

Boris Johnson saw his House of Commons majority slashed in a key vote on social care, as 19 Tory MPs joined Labour to vote against the controversial cost cap while dozens of others stayed away.

Labour and some Tory MPs accused the PM of going back on his promise that no-one would be forced to sell their home to pay for care, after it became clear that means-tested contributions made by local authorities on behalf of some pensioners will not count towards the £86,000 cap.

Labour health spokesman Justin Madders told the Commons the scheme was "Robin Hood in reverse", taking from the poor to give to the rich. He added the change was "not fairness" and "not fixing social care" - but "betrayal".

Our political editor Andrew Woodcock reports:

Boris Johnson sees off Tory rebellion over controversial cap on social care costs

Hello, and welcome to The Independent's rolling politics coverage. Stay tuned as bring you the latest reaction to last night's Commons vote, which saw ministers and MPs back the controversial amendment to a funding cost cap in England.

mardi 23 novembre 2021 12:43:42 Categories: The Independent

ShareButton
ShareButton
ShareButton
  • RSS

Suomi sisu kantaa
NorpaNet Beta 1.1.0.18818 - Firebird 5.0 LI-V6.3.2.1497

TetraSys Oy.

TetraSys Oy.